Body Types, Brains, and Flippin’ Morons

      141 Comments on Body Types, Brains, and Flippin’ Morons

Here’s part of what I wrote in a recent post titled Body Types and Brains:

I remember one of my roommates in college looking at the single spiral notebook I took to all my classes and saying, “That’s all the notes you take? How the heck are you getting A’s in everything? You hardly write anything down!”

“Uh, well,” I mumbled, “if the professor says something and it makes sense, I just remember it. I don’t really have to write much of it down.”

That particular roommate was a party animal. I partied right along with him, but only on Thursdays (dollar pitcher night), Fridays (quarter beer night) and Saturdays (student parties all over campus and near-campus).

I had another roommate for half of my senior year who was a studying machine. He not only took copious notes in class, he’d rewrite them all in neat penmanship later.  The notes he took in class were “too messy,” you see.  He attended the occasional party, but never drank much. We graduated with identical grade-point averages: just a fraction under a perfect 4.0/4.0, which means we both got a B in a class at some point. I remember him once asking me, “Why is it that you can party like [the first roommate] and then get the same grades I do?”

“Uh … I don’t know,” I said. “I channel both of you?”

Actually, I explained why I got those grades in the Body Types and Brains post:

I got those grades largely because I’m a “brain mesomorph,” so to speak. Brain mesomorphs can pick pretty much any method of studying and still do well, as long as they don’t do something to screw up that genetic gift – like, say, don’t study at all.

Well, I’ve changed my mind. I now believe I got (almost) straight A’s because I had the discipline to take a few notes in class, study a bit to master the material, turn in my papers on time, and limit my heavy beer-drinking to three nights per week. In fact, I think everyone could pull straight A’s in college if they were just willing to do the same.

To prove my theory, I’m going to re-enroll in college as a one-man experiment. This time around, I’ll drink copious amounts of beer six nights per week, skip the note-taking entirely, not bother studying, and turn in half-assed first drafts of my papers a week late. I suspect this will lead to no better than a C average, perhaps even worse.

If that’s the result, I’ll announce that I’ve proved my theory: anyone who doesn’t do extremely well in college simply isn’t willing to take a few notes, study a bit, and limit the partying to no more than three nights per week. Those B and C students have no one to blame but themselves.

Say what? You think my theory is bogus and my experiment is stupid?

Yes, of course it is. Academic achievement was easy for me, and screwing up on purpose to get average grades proves absolutely nothing about why other people get average grades.

As part of an extra-credit program in high school, I tutored another student who was struggling with freshman algebra. (I was a junior, which means I was taking trigonometry at the time.) This kid certainly put out the effort – more than I ever had to – but had a difficult time wrapping his brain around mathematical concepts. I felt sorry for him … because even at age 17, I had enough common sense not to blame people for being less than genetically gifted.

Unlike this nincompoop:

A woman who intentionally gained 50 pounds wants to demonstrate a point she believes about overweight people: They have only themselves to blame for being heavy.

“People have always said to me, all of my life, ‘You’re lucky to be skinny,’ and what I wanted to prove was that there are no excuses for being overweight,” British reality star Katie Hopkins told TODAY.

Ahh, I see. You’ve always been skinny, so of course you know all about what causes obesity. Are you by any chance related to MeMe Roth?  Your “before” picture suggests as much:

Hmmm, maybe you should get in touch with Heath Squier of Julian Bakery and ask him how to puff out your belly to look a teensy bit fat, then claim you were 35 pounds heavier.  Anyway …

Known across the pond for her acerbic, outspoken comments, Hopkins created a Twitter frenzy when she declared on a British talk show: “I don’t believe you can be fat and happy. I think that’s just a cop out.”

Critics immediately accused Hopkins of “fat shaming” and failing to understand the psychological, as well as physical, factors behind weight gain.

Hopkins then fought back against those who called her ignorant and wrong by eating. A lot. She consumed 6,500 calories every day by stuffing herself with calorie-rich burgers, fries, pasta and cupcakes, recording everything in a food journal. At times, she brought herself to tears because of how much she ate.

“I didn’t cry at childbirth. I didn’t cry at my wedding, but I cried over this because I was just so disgusting,” she said.

So to gain weight, you had to stuff yourself with 6,500 calories per day and eat until you were disgusted and in tears – in other words, waaaaay beyond what your appetite would dictate – just like all fat people do. Geez, and to think some critics actually doubted you understand the physical factors behind weight gain.

Hopkins admits the next step of her experiment has proved to be much more difficult. She’s committed to losing the 50 pounds she gained within three months. She has drastically changed her diet and upped her exercise level, all to prove that being thin is as simple as eating less and moving more.

So it’s a simple matter of eating less and moving more! Well, hell, why didn’t anyone ever tell me that during all those years I was making myself ravenous on low-calorie, low-fat diets and spending hours and hours on a treadmill? Clearly I didn’t try hard enough.

“I’ve learned a lot about how it feels to be big, how difficult it is to be big, how horrible it is to have fat sitting on the top of your thighs, and how much more challenging it is just to do everyday life when you’re bigger,” she said.

Hopkins said she still has 35 pounds left to lose in the next two months.

And I bet she’ll do it – because she’s been skinny her whole life and that’s the shape her body will want to resume.  (Simple math says she already lost 15 pounds in the first month; i.e., nearly four pounds per week.) To quote again from my Body Types and Brains post:

Mesomorphs look well built without setting foot in a gym … Yup. I’ve known people like that. In order to stay lean and muscular, all they really have to do is not screw up.

So this naturally-thin bubblehead screwed up on purpose by jamming 6,500 calories per day of junk food down her throat, thus overwhelming her body’s resistance to gaining weight, and by gosh, she got fat. So that means anyone who’s fat must be screwing up just like she did. Uh-huh … and if I go back to college and party away all my evenings instead of studying and then wind up with average grades as a result, that means anyone who gets C’s in college is a screw-up who parties too much. Same (ahem) logic.

Ms. Hopkins, you were born on the metabolic finish line and think you won a race. Not only that, you think you’re an expert on how the race is won – because you tied your ankles together and proved how difficult it is to run a race in that condition.

What you actually proved is that you’re a flippin’ moron.

Whoops … there I go, making judgments about someone born with a low I.Q.

Sorry about that.

Share

141 thoughts on “Body Types, Brains, and Flippin’ Morons

  1. Claude Benshaul

    Well said Tom!

    Another anecdotal evidence supporting my theory that one should never listen to health or nutrition advise from anyone who’s under 40 and/or has never been seriously sick or fat in it’s life.

    This imbecile just managed to prove that a low IQ will protect you from obesity.

    Reply
    1. Tom Naughton

      “Don’t trust anyone under 40.” Sort of the flipside of the counter-culture rallying cry from the 1960s.

      Reply
  2. Claude Benshaul

    Well said Tom!

    Another anecdotal evidence supporting my theory that one should never listen to health or nutrition advise from anyone who’s under 40 and/or has never been seriously sick or fat in it’s life.

    This imbecile just managed to prove that a low IQ will protect you from obesity.

    Reply
    1. Tom Naughton Post author

      “Don’t trust anyone under 40.” Sort of the flipside of the counter-culture rallying cry from the 1960s.

      Reply
  3. Joe

    Hi Tom.

    Excellent article here. Humans have genetic variation in just about everything so why not Fat accumulation too? What about athletics? Maybe the only reason I could never dunk a basketball is because I just never did enough leg presses. I had a friend in high school that was about my same height and weight that pretty much spent all day eating Cheetos and playing video games. He could dunk. He also smoked….a lot. I was proud of myself if I touched the backboard and I was working out regularly. Different genetics. I never had raw explosive power, but I was the mile runner on our track team and could pretty much take all my more athletic friends at distance. Now I know that I probably had differnt types of muscle fibers than my friends. Here’s an idea for our naturally cut and lean friends that think all fat people are lazy gluttons: let’s do an experiment like Dr. Lustig suggests and over insulinize these people every time they eat. Wouldn’t it be interesting to see if the results differ?

    Reply
  4. Joe

    Hi Tom.

    Excellent article here. Humans have genetic variation in just about everything so why not Fat accumulation too? What about athletics? Maybe the only reason I could never dunk a basketball is because I just never did enough leg presses. I had a friend in high school that was about my same height and weight that pretty much spent all day eating Cheetos and playing video games. He could dunk. He also smoked….a lot. I was proud of myself if I touched the backboard and I was working out regularly. Different genetics. I never had raw explosive power, but I was the mile runner on our track team and could pretty much take all my more athletic friends at distance. Now I know that I probably had differnt types of muscle fibers than my friends. Here’s an idea for our naturally cut and lean friends that think all fat people are lazy gluttons: let’s do an experiment like Dr. Lustig suggests and over insulinize these people every time they eat. Wouldn’t it be interesting to see if the results differ?

    Reply
  5. bob

    she`s well known in England for being an obnoxious prick . she writes articles for a tabloid paper . her goal in life is to upset as many people as possible . best to ignore the stupid cow !

    Reply
  6. bob

    she`s well known in England for being an obnoxious prick . she writes articles for a tabloid paper . her goal in life is to upset as many people as possible . best to ignore the stupid cow !

    Reply
  7. Mike

    I think it was 60-Minutes that explained how they use mesomorph athletes to do those before & after shots for the various shady diet products that one sees in advertisements. The manufacturer finds an athlete who has been temporarily injured and pays him to seriously overfeed while waiting for the injury to heal. Then they take a before photo and have the person use their amazing weight loss solution while they resume their usual level of activity. The weight comes off, the six-pack comes back, and then the manufacturer takes an after photo. It’s a diet miracle.

    Reply
  8. Mike

    I think it was 60-Minutes that explained how they use mesomorph athletes to do those before & after shots for the various shady diet products that one sees in advertisements. The manufacturer finds an athlete who has been temporarily injured and pays him to seriously overfeed while waiting for the injury to heal. Then they take a before photo and have the person use their amazing weight loss solution while they resume their usual level of activity. The weight comes off, the six-pack comes back, and then the manufacturer takes an after photo. It’s a diet miracle.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.